On 2 september 1998, trial chamber i of the tribunal found him guilty of nine out of fifteen counts charging him with genocide, crimes against humanity and violations of the geneva conventions in the first ever trial before the tribunal. Ferdinand nahimana, jeanbosco barayagwiza and hassan ngeze, case no. More generally, the judges affirm that, as stated in article 3 of the ictrs statute, a. In june 1997, the prosecutor amended the akayesu indictment to include charges of sexual violence. Akayesu, jean paul ictr964 united nations international. Case information sheet international criminal court. It was amended during the trial, in june 1997, with the addition of three counts to 15 and three paragraphs 10a, 12a and 12b. Respondents briefpage 7 file of army knew these words by indirect hearings.
The prosecutor filed charges against akayesu before the ictr on february, 1996. At the start of his trial, akayesu faced 12 charges of genocide, crimes against humanity and violations of common article 3. International criminal tribunal for rwanda ictr author. Filings for this case in the judicial records and archives database. A list of designations and abbreviations used in this appeals judgment is included in annex c.
Amended indictment at the end of the prosecution case, in may 1997. Ictr prosecutor v karemera, ngirumpatse, nzirorera decision on prosecutors interlocutory appeal of decision on judicial notice case no ictr9844ar73c ictr prosecutor v muvunyi trial chamber. The indictment against jeanpaul akayesu was submitted by the prosecutor on february 1996 and was confirmed on 16 february 1996. The failure by the prosecutor to pursue investigating and convicting akayesu on charges of rape in the face of testimony of rape at trial leaves the impression that the tribunal does not consider rape and sexual violence to be as important an offence as other offences and is. Since the submission of the amicus brief, the coalition has continued working to encourage the. On 2 september 1998, trial chamber i of the tribunal found him guilty of nine out of fifteen counts charging him with genocide, crimes against humanity and violations of the geneva conventions in. Akayesu case pdf jeanpaul akayesu born is a former teacher, school inspector, and republican. The prosecution of incitement to genocide in south africa. The accused, jeanpaul akayesu, was the mayor of taba, rwanda. During the 1994 rwandan genocide, jeanpaul akayesu served as the mayor of taba, a city in which thousands of tutsis were systematically raped, tortured and murdered. Akayesu, trial chamber 1 found that it was established beyond reasonable doubt that. Jeanpaul akayesu, heralded the legacy of the tribunal in prosecuting crimes of sexual. Ictr964t, 2 september 1998 and sentencing judgment, the prosecutor v.
Akayesu, convicted the defendant of the same charge. Carla del ponte solomon loh wenqu zhu mathias marcussen sonja boelaertsuominen morris anyah. Trial chamber i ictr published on by oxford university press. Sentence of life imprisonment affirmed on appeal on 1 june 2001. Sitting as trial chamber 1, composed of judge laity kama, presiding, judge lennart aspegren and judge navanethem pillay, considering that on 2 september 1998 a judgement was rendered by this chamber in the matter of the prosecutor versus jeanpaul akayesu. Jurisprudence of the international tribunal for former yugoslavia icty tended to pull in the opposite direction at times as well. The prosecutor of the tribunal against jeanpaul akayesu sentencing judgement cite as. He was the mayor of taba commune in gitarama prefecture from april 1993 until june 1994. Tadic, trial chamber ii held that persecution is a form of discrimination on grounds of race, religion or political opinion that is intended to be, and results in, an infringement of an individuals fundamental rights. The cases united nations international criminal tribunal. The akayesu case before the international criminal tribunal for rwanda. Punishment for violations of international criminal law.
Guest lecture series of the office of the prosecutor. The akayesu case before the international criminal tribunal for rwanda2008. Jeanpaul akayesu trial judgement, ictr964t, international criminal tribunal for rwanda ictr, 2 september 1998, available at. The indictment was confirmed on february 16 of the same year. The tribunal was established by united nations security council resolution.
Akayesu judgment pdf the judgment was appealed before the appeals chamber, which issued its judgment on 1 june the prosecutor. In fact, article 91 subparagraph 4 provides that an. Under the ictrs statute, ngeze was convicted under article 61, which provides for individual responsibility for someone who planned, instigated, ordered, committed or otherwise aided and abetted in the planning, preparation or execution of a crime under the ictr. Akayesu temporarily, as exemplified by the detours taken by the prosecutor v. The appeals chamber decreased krstics sentence to thirtyfive years after determining that krstic aided and abetted genocide rather than having functioned as a coperpetrator, as originally determined by the trial chamber. The failure by the prosecutor to pursue investigating and convicting akayesu on charges of rape in the face of testimony of rape at trial leaves the impression that the tribunal does not consider rape and sexual violence to be as important an offence as other offences and is thereby discriminatory to women. Aug 12, 2019 akayesu judgment pdf the judgment was appealed before the appeals chamber, which issued its judgment on 1 june the prosecutor v. Introduction the first judgment of the international criminal tribunal for rwanda ictr, prosecutor v.
The list in article 4 of the statute thus comprises serious violations of the. It happened to be the first time that the genocide convention had been put into practice. Akayesu is individually, criminally responsible for the killing of and causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the tutsi group. The case arose out of the massacres of perhaps a million tutsi in. Rwanda tribunal to rule on akayesu case human rights watch. The prosecutor of the international criminal tribunal for rwanda, pursuant to his authority under article 17 of the statute tribunal, ch akayesu with genocide, crimes against humanity and violations of article 3 common to the geneva conventions, as set forth below. Akayesu judgment pdf the judgment was appealed before the appeals chamber, which issued its judgment on 1 june the prosecutor v. He was the mayor of taba commune in gitarama prefecture from april 1993 until june 1994 as mayor, akayesu was responsible for performing executive functions and maintaining order in taba, meaning he had command of the communal police and any. Gender crimes and crimes of sexual violence are no longer as invisible as they once were thanks largely to the work of feminist scholars, practitioners, and activists, and. Akayesu is serving his sentence in a prison in mali. The present judgment constitutes the firstever judgment by an international court for the crime of genocide.
As mayor, akayesu was responsible for performing executive functions and maintaining order in taba, meaning. Jeanpierre bemba gombo on 10 may 2007, the prosecutor informed the government of the central african republic, pretrial chamber iii and the president of the court of his decision to open an investigation. International criminal tribunal for rwanda, september 2, 1998. Jun 01, 2001 the accused, jeanpaul akayesu, was the mayor of taba, rwanda. Jeanpaul akayesu born 1953, taba, rwanda is a former teacher, school inspector, and republican democratic movement mdr politician from rwanda. The indictment against jeanpaul akayesu was submitted by the prosecutor on febmary 1996 and was confirmed on 16 february 1996. Jeanpaul akayesu by virtue of his position of authority, his encouragement sent a clear signal of official tolerance for sexual violence, without which alayesu acts could not have taken place. It was amended during the trial, in june 1997, with the addition of three counts to 15 and paragraphs loa, l2a 128. Prosecutor v akayesu jean paul, sentencing judgment. Tadic, trial chamber ii held that persecution is a form of discrimination on grounds of race, religion or political opinion that is intended to be, and results in, an infringement of an individuals fundamental rights as mentioned above, this is a broad definition which could include acts prohibited under other subheadings. Jun 28, 2019 akayesu judgment pdf the judgment was appealed before the appeals chamber, which issued its judgment on 1 june the prosecutor v. Ictr9952t, is rendered by trial chamber i the chamber of the international criminal tribunal for rwanda the tribunal. Prosecutor v akayesu jean paul, sentencing judgment, case. Sep 08, 2019 akayesu judgment pdf the judgment was appealed before the appeals chamber, which issued its judgment on 1 june the prosecutor v.
The prosecutor of the tribunal against jeanpaul akayesu. This pioneering opinion marks the first time an international criminal tribunal has tried and convicted an individual for genocide and international crimes of sexual violence. It included 15 charges for genocide, crimes against humanity, and violations of article 3 common to the geneva conventions and additional protocol 2. Footnotes trial judgment, paras and emphasis added. The case that i prosecuted on behalf of the international criminal tribunal for rwanda was the case of the prosecutor v. The accused, jeanpaul akayesu, was the bourgmestre mayor of taba and was indicted on 15 counts of genocide, crimes against humanity and violations of article 3 common to the geneva conventions and additional protocol ii thereto. Legacy website of the international criminal tribunal for rwanda. In this sense, the rwandan pend code provides that direct and public incitement or provocation is a form of complicity. Miller, from the international criminal tribunal for rwanda to the inter national criminal court.
1373 976 1071 577 1293 298 830 813 778 699 1527 206 1202 795 513 1017 1469 601 402 157 602 114 509 27 1183 709 1231 862 1286 1046 325 317 160 593 837 1246 876 1387 97 840 1284 187 87 771 834